
Does forcing people to seperate their recyclables encourage recycling, or switch them off? Picture: edie.
To seperate or not to seperate, that is the question…
Just a couple of weeks ago it was reported that local authorities in the UK will have to force residents to separate their recyclables by law. This is fine if you are a bean eating, tree hugging environmentalist, but surely it’s not the best way to get people to recycle?
Our local authority, South Holland in Lincolnshire, not only provides weekly collections for both black bag waste and recyclables, but also co-mingles the latter. Eschewing wheelie bins in much of its rural area it relies on green bags (issued to householders), as well as any spare cardboard boxes, clear bags or similar that people wish to use.
South Holland District Council achieved a recycling rate of 32.84% in 2008/09. True, this is a long way off the 61.84% achieved by Staffordshire Moorlands District Council at the top of the table, but it’s also more than double the worst performing authority – Ashford in Kent.
So, why is co-mingling a dirty word? South-Holland’s two container evidently works better than many other councils with greater degrees of sorting, and the technology exists to sort recyclable waste efficiently. In fact, the recent experience of Biffa suggests that co-mingling makes recycling easier, boosting rates. It should also help secure feedstocks for EfW plants.
I might not agree with everything our council does, but on waste collection, apart from not collecting green waste, they deserve a big thumbs up!